We stayed here for 3 nights and we loved it. We were lucky to have the upper room, inside the rock, like one of the caves in Capadocia. The room was very clean and comfortable and the balcony has a great view. The staff helped us a lot with everything we needed (tours, transfers, motor rent, advice, etc) and everyone was very very friendly, doing their best to make everything perfect for us.
We'll definitely stay there again if we go back to Goreme one day. We strongly recommend Emily's.